Published November 12, 2026
Why Your Property Taxes Can Jump After You Buy: Michigan's "Uncapping" Rule Explained for Livingston County Buyers
Most buyers look at the property tax number on a listing and assume that's what they'll pay. It's a fair assumption. In a lot of states, it's close.
In Michigan, it often isn't. The taxes the current owner pays can be a lot lower than what you'll pay after you buy, and the difference can show up a year after closing, long after you've settled into your payment. I see it most often in Brighton, Howell, Hartland, Pinckney and Fowlerville when someone buys from a seller who's owned the home for a long time.
With winter tax bills going out around the first of December, this is a good time to walk through how it works so it doesn't catch you off guard.
The Short Version: Proposal A and "Uncapping"
Since Michigan voters passed Proposal A in 1994, a home has two values that matter for taxes:
- State Equalized Value (SEV): roughly half of what the assessor thinks the home is worth on the market.
- Taxable Value: the number your taxes are actually figured on.
While someone owns a home, the taxable value can only rise each year by the rate of inflation or 5%, whichever is less, plus any new additions. Home values have climbed much faster than that over the years, so a long-time owner's taxable value can sit well below the SEV.
When the home sells, the cap comes off. In the year after the transfer, taxable value "uncaps" and resets to the SEV. That's the jump. The seller's tax bill reflects their years of capped increases. Yours won't.
Pro Tip: Don't budget from the seller's tax history. Ask for a rough estimate based on the current SEV and the local millage rate, or call the township or city assessor's office. They field this question all the time.
Why It Hits Some Homes Harder Than Others
The longer the seller has owned the home, and the more values have risen in that area, the bigger the gap tends to be. A lake home or a farmhouse on acreage that's been in the same family for 20 years can have a very different tax picture than a newer subdivision home that last sold a few years ago.
Millage also varies a lot from one township, city and school district to the next. Two homes a few miles apart in Livingston County, or across the line into Ingham or Oakland County, can carry noticeably different rates.
Pro Tip: When we're comparing homes, look at the estimated taxes after uncapping for each one. A slightly higher price with a lower millage can come out ahead of a "cheaper" house over a few years.
Your Lender May Already Be Planning for It, or Not
If your taxes are paid through an escrow account, your lender estimates them up front. Some lenders estimate based on the purchase price. Others use the seller's last bill. If they use the seller's number, your escrow can come up short once the new bill arrives, and your monthly payment goes up to cover the shortage.
That's not a disaster, but it's a surprise nobody wants in the second year of owning a home.
Pro Tip: Ask your loan officer directly, "Are you estimating my taxes on the uncapped value or the seller's current bill?" If it's the seller's bill, you may want a cushion in your budget.
Don't Skip the Principal Residence Exemption
This one matters just as much as uncapping. If the home is going to be your main residence, you can claim Michigan's Principal Residence Exemption (PRE), sometimes still called the homestead exemption. It exempts your home from a large share of the local school operating millage, and on many homes that's a meaningful savings.
It isn't automatic. You file Form 2368 with your local assessor, usually at closing or shortly after. If you buy and move in, make sure it gets filed. If you're buying a second home, rental or cottage, you generally won't qualify, so plan for the higher rate.
Pro Tip: Your title company usually hands you the PRE affidavit at closing. Sign it there if the home is your primary residence. It's one of the easiest ways to keep your taxes from running higher than they need to.
One More Form: The Property Transfer Affidavit
Michigan also requires buyers to file a Property Transfer Affidavit (Form 2766) with the assessor within 45 days of the transfer. It's how the assessor knows the home sold and the taxable value should uncap. Missing it can come with a penalty, so it's worth confirming it's handled. Again, the title company often helps with this.
What Sellers Should Know
If you're selling, your buyer's taxes probably aren't going to match yours, and a sharp buyer's agent will point that out. It's not a reason to drop your price, but it does help to understand why a buyer might bring it up. Being upfront about your current bill, and noting that the new owner's will likely be different, keeps the conversation honest and avoids friction later.
Sellers also see property taxes split at closing. How that proration is figured can vary, so look at your settlement statement carefully and ask questions if the numbers don't make sense.
Keep Reading
- Buying Over the Holidays? How to Keep Your Mortgage Approval on Track Through Closing
- Will They Insure This House? What Home Insurance Can Do to a Livingston County Deal
- Fix It, Credit It, or Cut the Price? Negotiating After the Inspection in Livingston County
The Bottom Line
The tax number on the listing is a starting point, not a promise. Estimate your taxes on the uncapped value, ask your lender how they're figuring escrow, and make sure your Principal Residence Exemption gets filed. A few minutes of homework up front can save you a real surprise a year from now.
I'm not a tax advisor, so for your exact situation the assessor's office or a tax professional is the final word. But if you're buying or selling around Brighton, Howell, Hartland, Pinckney, Fowlerville or Lansing and want help comparing what a home will really cost to own, call or text me at 810-522-0558.
Devin Fink | DJF Properties | Rademacher Team and Associates | KW Professionals
Photo: Dwight Burdette, McPherson Mansion, Howell, Michigan, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0. Resized.
